Palmilla Beach Resort & Golf Community and Cinnamon Shore are the two top luxury vacation rental communities in Port Aransas, Texas, both located on Mustang Island along the Gulf Coast. They’re neighbors — less than a mile apart — and both offer upscale beach houses and condos, resort-style pools, on-site restaurants, boardwalk beach access, and golf cart culture. If you’re planning a beach trip to Port A, the question isn’t really “which is better” — it’s which one fits what you’re looking for. Here’s a side-by-side breakdown.
Location and Setting
Both communities sit on the Gulf side of Mustang Island, south of the main Port Aransas town center. Cinnamon Shore is the more established of the two — it’s been operating longer and has a more “finished” feel, with pastel-colored beach houses, manicured lakes and ponds, landscaped streets, and a polished, neighborhood atmosphere. Palmilla Beach is newer and still actively developing (expect some construction visibility), but the master plan includes natural lakes, nine manicured pocket parks, and a coastal village layout. Both are about a 5-minute walk over the dunes to the beach, and both offer boardwalk access for golf carts.
Pools
Cinnamon Shore has three pools: Kiera (the main family pool, heated, with an attached bar and restaurant — this is where most families hang out), Still Water (a smaller, quieter heated pool), and Dune (adjacent to the fitness center and playground, not heated — best in summer). Kiera is the social hub of the community.
Palmilla Beach has two pools: The Oasis (a large lagoon-style pool with zero-slope entry, a giant splash pad, private cabanas, and the only swim-up bar in Port Aransas — Skipjacks bar and grill) and the Seaside Pool (with its own dining service). Both Palmilla pools are heated and open year-round. Palmilla’s pool complex is newer and more resort-style; Cinnamon Shore’s pools are more spread out and integrated into the neighborhood.
Dining
Cinnamon Shore has several on-site options including Lisabella’s (a local favorite for dinner — you don’t need to be a Cinnamon Shore guest to dine here), Dylan’s Pizzeria, and Shore Café. The dining scene is well-established and there’s enough variety that you don’t need to leave the community for meals.
Palmilla Beach has five dining and drink spots within the village: The Black Marlin Seaside Grill (the signature restaurant — fresh seafood and steaks, award-winning), REDS Patio Bar (upscale outdoor bar with music and ocean breezes), Skipjacks (swim-up bar and poolside grill at The Oasis), Agave Poolside Cantina (at the Seaside Pool), and Blue Marlin. Palmilla’s dining lineup is newer and oriented more toward a resort-dining experience.
Golf
This is Palmilla’s biggest differentiator. Palmilla Beach has the only true links-style golf course in Texas — originally designed by Arnold Palmer, with 9 holes of regular play plus “The Loop” (a 3-hole par-3 short course) and a driving range and putting green. The course winds through the community with Gulf of Mexico views and has been ranked by Golfweek in the top 1% nationally. No membership required — the course is open to the public with a beach-casual dress code.
Cinnamon Shore does not have a golf course. If golf matters to your group, Palmilla wins this category outright.
Beach Access
Both communities have boardwalk beach access that you can walk or drive a golf cart on, and both offer complimentary beach chairs for owners and guests. Palmilla has a more developed beach service: a designated VIP beach area with food and drink service, air-conditioned comfort stations (bathrooms) right on the beach, and poolside-style cabana rentals. Cinnamon Shore offers umbrella and chair service as well, but its beach setup is simpler. Both communities use a two-way boardwalk system to manage golf cart traffic to and from the beach.
Accommodations
Both communities operate as vacation rental properties — you’re booking a privately owned home or condo through the community’s rental program or through platforms like VRBO, Vacasa, or Expedia. Expect full kitchens, washers/dryers, smart TVs, multiple bedrooms, and premium furnishings at both. Cinnamon Shore has a wider range of established inventory — from three-story beach houses to single-story condos — and its units have a reputation for consistently high-quality interiors. Palmilla Beach has newer construction (townhomes, condos, and single-family homes) with modern finishes, though inventory is still growing. Both offer pet-friendly options (check individual listings).
Activities and Atmosphere
Cinnamon Shore has fishing piers, lawn games (cornhole, giant chess), bike rentals, beach fitness classes, live music events, bonfires with s’mores, and a weekly activities calendar. The vibe is polished family neighborhood — people ride cruisers and golf carts, kids are everywhere, and the pace is relaxed. It feels like a community, not a hotel.
Palmilla Beach has nine pocket parks (with firepits, swings, bocce ball), a fitness center, a weekly events and activities calendar, and guest services that can arrange golf carts, cabanas, and beach equipment. The vibe is more “resort village” — slightly more curated and service-oriented, less established-neighborhood.
Pricing
Both communities are at the premium end of Port Aransas pricing. Rates vary by property size, season, and how far in advance you book. During peak summer, expect multi-bedroom houses to run $400–$800+ per night at either community, with smaller condos starting lower. HOA fees for owners are substantial at both (a factor if you’re considering buying, not just renting). Neither community is a budget option — these are the most upscale rental communities on Mustang Island.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Palmilla Beach if: Golf is important to your group. You want the newest construction and a more resort-style pool experience (swim-up bar, VIP beach service). You don’t mind that the community is still developing and some construction may be visible.
Choose Cinnamon Shore if: You want the more established, finished community with a proven track record. You prefer a neighborhood feel with multiple pool options spread out. You want a wider selection of rental properties and a dining scene (especially Lisabella’s) that’s been operating longer.
Either way: You’re getting luxury beachfront living on Mustang Island with Gulf beach access, pools, restaurants, and the laid-back Port Aransas atmosphere. They’re a 2–3 minute golf cart ride apart, and guests at one can dine at the other’s restaurants. You can’t go wrong.
Getting to Port Aransas
Port Aransas is on Mustang Island, accessible via the Port Aransas ferry (free, runs 24/7 from Aransas Pass) or by driving south from Corpus Christi across the JFK Causeway and up Mustang Island. From San Antonio: ~2.5 hours. From Houston: ~3.5 hours. From Austin: ~3.5 hours. From Dallas: ~6 hours. The nearest commercial airport is Corpus Christi International (CRP), about 45 minutes from Port Aransas.
For more Texas beach and coastal travel, see fishing excursions in Texas, dog-friendly beaches in Florida, Dauphin Island activities, and fishing getaways for couples in Texas.
Proud owner of https://travelyouman.com/